|
Post by Lexi on Oct 15, 2009 8:50:53 GMT
Since the last one got a little big I'm opening a new one so here is the last 'this or that' posted in the previous thread:
Piper Season's 1-3 or Piper Season's 4-8
I prefered Piper in season 1-3 as the middle child. She may have grown up a little in the later seasons bu her character just changed from the PIper that we grew to know and she turned extremely whiny. Yes, season 1-3 she mentioned all she wanted was a normal life but she still saved innocents without question.
So...Phoebe 1-4 or Phoebe 5-8?
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 17, 2009 2:16:23 GMT
I'm definitely with you regarding Piper.
I also definitely prefer Phoebe S1-4. Although I liked my Phoebs best during S1-2, she definitely went downhill after she vanquished Cole the first time. The way she treated him like a bag of dirt when she had been just as bad as the Queen of the Underworld was sickening. And once she had her visionquest and suddenly forcing her premonitions to help her find her daughter's sperm donor (who cares about love?) was totally disgusting.
So....S1 Leo or S8 Leo?
|
|
|
Post by Matriarch Goddess on Nov 17, 2009 10:39:09 GMT
S1 Leo
Piper S5 or Piper S6
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 17, 2009 14:26:04 GMT
If you don't count "Oh, My Goddess!", S5 Piper. I can't stand Piper starting with "Oh, My Goddess" forward -- she became SO cold and SO selfish and SO self-centered. Miss Whinealot. It's why I say that "Oh, My Goddess!" starts Charmed's first spin-off: "The Perils of Poor, Poor, Pititful Piper."
S6 Big Wyatt or S7 Big Wyatt?
|
|
|
Post by Matriarch Goddess on Nov 19, 2009 10:09:57 GMT
toughy!!!
but it will have to be S7 Wyatt
S1 Prue or S3 Prue
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 21, 2009 7:12:10 GMT
S1 Prue. By S3, Kern was beginning to corrupt her the way he corrupted her sisters. I'm so glad he didn't get a chance to finish the job.
S4 Paige or S8 Paige?
|
|
|
Post by matthew on Nov 22, 2009 14:21:33 GMT
S4 - Paige
She was fun to watch, doing her own things, trying to combat demons, trying to figure her powers out and her mishaps with spells and potions.
Power of three as - Prue, Piper & Phoebe Or Piper, Phoebe & Paige?
|
|
|
Post by Matriarch Goddess on Nov 23, 2009 10:04:19 GMT
Piper, Phoebe & Paige
Leo or Dan Gordon
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on Nov 26, 2009 4:02:07 GMT
Good to have you in this thread, Matthew; I love that you also tell why you make the choices you do--I agree with you totally as far as Paige goes.
Had I got to answer you I wouldn't have needed a second to think about it--the Original Power of Three, hands down! Nothing against Paige, my favorite of the second set, but everything about three sisters who happened to be witches, not three demon-slayers who happened to live in the same house.
As for Leo or Dan, had Piper never gotten her clutches into him, my angel will always be my favorite, but for Piper, Dan would've been SOOOO much better for her--no more whining about a normal life because Dan could've given her that at home.
For Piper (if she had never met Leo): Jason or Henry?
|
|
|
Post by matthew on Nov 30, 2009 17:11:01 GMT
Oh Cheers Es, its nice to be jumping up and down from every board down here. For Piper, I would go for Jason - Mainly because Jason can be the counterpart for Leo, blonde and blue, hot hunk, so if Wyatt was to be born into the Halliwells, he would still be hot guy. Paige as a red hair or Blonde Hair?
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on Dec 1, 2009 1:08:03 GMT
LOL! I should've guess that you'd think about what's best for Wyatt's looks! But was Jason a blond? I thought Jesse was, not Jason.
Well, the true reply is neither; I prefer Paige as a brunette, but between the two I'd probably have to say a red-head. The blonder she got, the ditzier she got (I always swore that all of that peroxide went straight to her brain!) and I liked her when she was smart.
Leo as the Elder or Leo as the Avatar?
|
|
|
Post by Matriarch Goddess on Mar 27, 2010 9:58:42 GMT
Leo as a Avatar
Fairies or Nymphs
|
|
|
Post by Lexi on Jun 8, 2010 12:46:23 GMT
I've got to say Fairies - at least when the fairiest first showed up it was stated that even though the sisters were magical they still couldn't see them without the spell and really believing in them. When Paige came along, they forgot all about that and just used the whole reason of her being magical - which then brought the nymphs.
So definitely Fairies - plus I loved Kate she was so adorable.
Hmm....If Piper and Leo never had the chance to meet and marry which sister would Leo have best been with: Prue or Phoebe or Paige
(I know I'm only meant to have two options but I just want to get this game going again...)
|
|
|
Post by christopher on Jun 13, 2010 22:21:34 GMT
Um, Leo and Paige the whitelighter personality seems to work well together.
Little Baby Chris or Future Chris Perry
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on Jun 14, 2010 18:42:18 GMT
Little Baby Chris by a long shot. Despite the fact that he was fugly and played by fugly twin girls, anything is better than the True Big Bad of Charmed who should've been named Brad, not Chris.
Phoebe's daughters as the next Charmed Ones or Piper's daughter, Phoebe's daughters and Paige's daughter as the next Power of Three? (hehehehe. Yes, Lexi, that's hyping your upcoming series!)
|
|