|
|
Post by Matriarch Goddess on Apr 25, 2009 9:22:36 GMT
P. Russell (Phoebe's past life)
water or fire
|
|
|
|
Post by Lexi on May 2, 2009 20:22:22 GMT
fire - even though I'm a water star sign!
S6 Chris or the evil Chris from the mirror world
|
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on May 3, 2009 2:28:43 GMT
OOO, that's hard because I hated both of them, especially because I didn't see that much differences between the two! S6 Chris because he was cuter than Evil Chris--that HORRIBLE hair style--he was almost as fugly as Chris in Forever Charmed!
The S4 Seer or The Evil Enchantress (Paige's past life)?
|
|
|
|
Post by Lexi on May 4, 2009 18:52:10 GMT
I know, i agree, there wasn't much difference between the two. That's why that one was interesting to ask.
Hmm, this is interesting. I loved the idea of the Evil Enchantress but hated it that they made Paige able to channel the powers - I can't see how that was possible. Just because she was Paige's past life, didn't mean that Paige would be able to channel her powers, they may have been the same soul but the soul lost those powers due to the misuse...
Anyway, I guess because of that I'll have to go with S4 Seer.
Dan, the neighbour, or Greg, the fireman?
|
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on May 7, 2009 17:59:19 GMT
 Sneaky of you, but I'm glad that you also noticed that there wasn't that much difference. A friend of mine thinks that's why the "evil" ones were more funny than evil...because the "good" ones were no longer all that good! *shakes head* All thanks to Chris! You're absolutely right about the fact that Paige shouldn't have been able to channel a power that she had lost--it would've been as bad as seeing Prue with that freezing power or Phoebe with her fire power that they had as the cousins. (I would've LOVED to have seen the lives they lived between their ones as the cousins and their ones as the Charmed Ones. They HAD to do some magnificently FANTASTICALLY whitelighter-type things in order to go from Evil Past Phoebe and Murderer Past Prue and Piper to The Charmed Ones!) Hmmm. That's another hard one. I felt sorry for both of them since Piper was simply using both of them while angry at Leo for putting his destiny in front of his love for her. I guess Dan because Piper actually liked him for reasons besides the fact that he was hot, the only reason she screwed Greg. Jenny Gordon or Billie Jenkins? |
|
|
|
Post by Lexi on May 9, 2009 18:00:48 GMT
Definitely, they must have done something really good. I think Past Prue and Piper murdering Past Phoebe just showed what they could, and what Piper pretty much did, become in S8.
Hm, as for Jenny or Billie. I didn't really like either but I think I'm going to go with Jenny. She was a child and didn't really know much better and at least she didn't take over the whole show which is how I thought Billie did.
Grams or Patty
|
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on May 10, 2009 0:40:16 GMT
Definitely, they must have done something really good. I think Past Prue and Piper murdering Past Phoebe just showed what they could, and what Piper pretty much did, become in S8. You're absolutely right about that...the reason why I don't think either Piper or Phoebe will have ANY powers in their next lives! And Chris? *shudder* I don't want to to think what sort of life he'll be stuck with living in *his* next lifetime, unless Baby Chris grown up is a WHOLE lot different than S6 Chris! Well, Billie *could've* taken over the whole world, but was too stupid to even try. WIthout The Charmed Ones stopping her, who knows what Christy (and Dumain and the Triad) might have done with Billie's powers. Another hard one. Although I hate the fact that Patty was screwing Sam behind Victor's back while still married to him (Phoebe takes after her...), except for that, she was always my favorite female character on Charmed, so I'll stick with her. Victor (as played by James Read...) or Leo? |
|
|
|
Post by christopher on May 12, 2009 0:18:28 GMT
Leo he's one of the greatest dad's out their, before the elders got him and after
human looking demons or monster looking demons
|
|
|
|
Post by Matriarch Goddess on May 12, 2009 11:24:02 GMT
human looking demons
Leo for Piper or Dan for Piper
|
|
|
|
Post by Lexi on May 12, 2009 15:20:51 GMT
It depends on what season we're going for to be honest. If I think of earlier Piper I would have said Leo but he was too good for her in later seasons so I would have to go with Dan, they seemed to deserve each other after he became the jealous type.
The mermaid storyline or the Valhalla storyline?
|
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on May 12, 2009 16:51:09 GMT
I also thought that Leo was too good for Piper in the earlier seasons and she wanted a normal life too much, something Leo could never give her. It's why I'll always believe that Piper would've been happiest with Dan. AND it means someone else would've been Leo's children's mother, someone who might have taught them that protecting innocents is more important than trying to live a normal life and trying to change an angel into your errand boy!
OH, you love giving me tough choices, don't you?? My two least-favorite storylines! But it would have to be the mermaid one. At least that wasn't the one that turned the Charmed Ones from potential whitelighters into potenial darklighters!
Cole becoming mortal or Leo becoming mortal?
|
|
|
|
Post by christopher on May 13, 2009 0:59:34 GMT
Leo becoming mortal cause when cole went mortal he just got whiney
shooting lightning bolts or fire streams
|
|
|
|
Post by Lexi on May 14, 2009 18:25:32 GMT
To be honest, so did Leo a little bit.
Anyway, hmm, i'll go with fire streams mainly because its fire!
S1 Victor or S3-8 Victor?
|
|
|
|
Post by Esmeralda on May 15, 2009 1:14:38 GMT
Oh, Leo did a LOT! He was SOOO annoying! He was SOOO not my angel anymore! GRRRR at Piper and Kern!
Oh, for once you gave me an easy one, Lexi!
Victor as played by James Read most definitely! I didn't care for the original Victor at all! The only good thing he did was giving the sisters the Christmas video!
Patty if she had been played by Alyssa Milano (who played her in the Christmas video) or Patty as played by Finola Hughes?
|
|
|
|
Post by Lexi on May 16, 2009 15:51:34 GMT
It was also Alyssa Milano in From Fear to Eternity, in the water!
Anyway, in answer to that, definitely Finola Hughes! I love her so much and she made Patty really come to life!
Paige as a social worker or Paige as a full time witch?
|
|
Sneaky of you, but I'm glad that you also noticed that there wasn't that much difference. A friend of mine thinks that's why the "evil" ones were more funny than evil...because the "good" ones were no longer all that good! *shakes head* All thanks to Chris!
